Gobotswang takes Gov’t to court over Land Board recruitment

Laone Rasaka40 minutes ago1117 min

Tswapong South MP and Botswana Congress Party (BCP) Shadow Minister for Lands and Agriculture Dr Kesitegile Gobotswang has launched a legal challenge against the government. He argues that a recruitment exercise could unlawfully alter the administration of tribal land without Parliament’s approval.

In an urgent application before the Gaborone High Court, Gobotswang has cited the Attorney General and the Public Enterprises Evaluation and Privatisation Agency (PEEPA). He says the government is seeking to bypass procedures set out in the Tribal Land Act of 2018.

In a founding affidavit sworn on 28 October 2026, Gobotswang challenges an expression of interest published by PEEPA on 7 October. The notice invited applications for three-year appointments to what it described as national and local “Land Governance” structures.

The recruitment exercise began only weeks before the terms of Land Board members across the country were due to expire in November 2026.

Gobotswang argues that the process has no legal basis and that PEEPA has no authority to recruit members of institutions responsible for administering tribal land on behalf of Batswana.

“This application raises a question of legality. It is whether the Executive may, through PEEPA, recruit the members of the bodies that hold the tribal land of Botswana in trust for its citizens by a process that Parliament has not authorised, on criteria that Parliament has not prescribed, and, in part, for bodies that the law does not yet recognise,” he states.

The MP says he wrote to the Minister of Lands on 11 October seeking an explanation of the legal authority for PEEPA’s role in the recruitment exercise. He gave the Minister until 14 October to respond and called for the process to be suspended.

Gobotswang claims the government did not respond. The recruitment exercise continued and closed without any explanation of its legal basis.

He asks the court to treat the Minister’s silence as evidence that the government cannot justify the process.

“The questions I asked were direct, and their answers lie peculiarly within the knowledge of the Minister. A lawful basis for the process, if one existed, could have been identified in a single paragraph. I respectfully submit that the Court may infer from the Minister’s silence that he is unable to identify one,” he says.

Gobotswang also rejects the suggestion that PEEPA is merely assisting the Ministry of Lands. He argues that the agency’s role goes beyond administrative support.

“PEEPA merely assists the Minister. A Minister may take advice. But the Expression of Interest is not advice to the Minister,” he says.

He further contends that the recruitment criteria place too much emphasis on professional qualifications and not enough on the knowledge and experience of local farmers and community members, who play an important role in tribal land administration.

The MP warns that appointments made through the PEEPA-led process could leave decisions by improperly constituted Land Boards open to legal challenges. Those decisions could include land allocations, grants and title cancellations. If overturned, they could create uncertainty for landholders, investors and homeowners.

Rather than bringing order to land governance, he cautions, the process could trigger confusion and further litigation across the affected tribal territories.

Gobotswang says he went to court because he believes there is no other effective way to challenge the legality of the recruitment exercise.

“The candidates who responded to the Expression of Interest are unlikely to sue the body from which they seek appointment. The serving members of Land Boards, whose terms are expiring, cannot do so. The public at large has no other champion in the matter,” he says.

In closing his affidavit, Gobotswang invokes Botswana’s longstanding commitment to constitutionalism and the rule of law. He argues that any changes to tribal land administration must be made through Parliament, not by executive action.

“Since independence, Botswana has been respected for its adherence to the rule of law and to constitutionalism. Any reform of the administration of tribal land, whatever its merits, proceeds through Parliament. Until Parliament amends the Act, the Minister is bound to constitute Land Boards in the manner that it prescribes, and PEEPA has no part in that process.”