Stop the bleeding first: Saleshando’s prescription for a nation living on one windfall

TSHEPANG MONNAATLALA2 hours ago41225 min

The Leader of the Opposition answered the State of the Nation Address not with a catalogue of grievances but with a six-point rescue plan – and a pointed warning that buying more of De Beers is not the same as owning more of Botswana’s future.

There is a moment in every diagnosis when the physician must choose between the long consultation and the urgent intervention. Dumelang Saleshando, the Leader of the Opposition and Member of Parliament for Maun North, reached for the second. “When a patient is haemorrhaging,” he told the National Assembly on 11 November, “the doctor does not begin by presenting a ten-year wellness plan. She stops the bleeding.”

It was the governing metaphor of his response to the third State of the Nation Address of this administration, a speech that spent less energy itemising what has gone wrong – the empty medicine shelves, the schools in disrepair, the graduates queuing for jobs that do not exist – than on prescribing what a government might do instead. Batswana, he argued, already know their lives have become harder. “They live it every day. What they need from this House is a way out.”

That is the frame worth taking seriously, because it reorders the usual choreography of opposition. Saleshando came not to narrate the decline but to contest the remedy.

The numbers beneath the number

His case began with a familiar suspicion: that the headline can flatter while the household suffers. The economy, he noted, shrank by 2.8 per cent in 2024 and a further 0.7 per cent in 2025. This year the figures brightened – annual growth of 3.7 per cent in the second quarter, a quarterly reading of 8.7 per cent – and he welcomed it. Then came the puncture. That rebound, he said, was diamond mining recovering from a very low base. The non-mining economy, “where most Batswana work and trade,” actually contracted by 0.2 per cent, and real household consumption fell by 7.2 per cent over the year, a figure he attributed to Econsult.

“The mines are producing more,” he said, “but households are consuming less. We must never confuse an increase in production with an improvement in the wellbeing of our people.”

The same scepticism met the public finances. Government, he acknowledged, has revised this year’s deficit sharply downward – from P26.35 billion, or 8.9 per cent of GDP, to roughly P9.3 billion, or 3.1 per cent. But P8.1 billion of that improvement, he insisted, was an upward revenue revision, most of it a one-off P7.3 billion distribution from the Bank of Botswana. “A one-off windfall is good fortune,” he said. “It is not reform.”

Behind the arithmetic sat the longer anxiety. Public debt is projected to reach 44.66 per cent of GDP by March 2027, far past the 40 per cent ceiling that Parliament was asked to lift to 60. Moody’s downgraded the country’s credit rating in September. Diamonds still supply about a third of government revenue and three-quarters of foreign exchange. “The dependency we have talked about for twenty years has not changed,” he said. “That, Mr Speaker, is the true state of the nation.”

Two clocks running at once

Saleshando’s organising proposition was that Botswana needs two economic programmes running simultaneously: an immediate rescue to lower the cost of living, protect jobs and put money back into circulation, and a long-term transformation to diversify exports and build new industries. The government, he conceded, has the second in the form of its transformation programme, the BETP. What it lacks, he argued, is the first – and the first cannot wait for the second. Railways, airports, industrial parks and solar plants may serve the future, “but many will take years to build and a decade to pay off. Families are cutting back today. Businesses are closing today. Young people need work today.”

The six-point rescue

From that premise he laid out an Economic Rescue Plan built on six priorities.

First, the cost of living. He pressed for targeted VAT relief on a wider basket of essentials – bathing and laundry soap, detergent, toothpaste, toilet paper – brought to Parliament with full costing and a mechanism to ensure the savings reach consumers “not profit margins.” He coupled it with a demand for a moratorium on new or increased levies on low- and middle-income families, singling out the user fees for customary court services introduced through Statutory Instrument No. 119 of 2026. For many Batswana, he said, the Kgotla is the only route to justice, and “justice must not carry a price the poor cannot pay.”

Second, the cost of government. The State, he argued, cannot ask households to tighten their belts while refusing to examine its own. He called for a cost-containment and reprioritisation plan from the Ministry of Finance, with quarterly public reporting on savings from centralised procurement – “tell the nation how much, where it was redirected, and what it did to service delivery.” The President, he suggested, should lead by example, recalling the early independence years when leaders travelled to international meetings with small delegations on commercial flights. He asked, too, that plans to open new diplomatic missions be shelved: “every new mission is a permanent cost,” and in this economy “that ambition must wait.”

Third, fuel as a national economic risk. When fuel becomes scarce or expensive, he observed, “every price in the economy rises with it.” He urged an open review of whether current procurement and distribution arrangements deliver the security they promised, a transparent and time-bound relief mechanism for public transport and productive sectors during price shocks, and wide consultation on the draft Botswana Energy Regulatory Authority Amendment Bill.

Fourth, purchasing power – and the State’s own debts. A worker whose salary stays flat while prices climb “has taken a pay cut.” He called for engagement with organised labour on a cost-of-living adjustment and a minimum-wage review. Here he turned a government promise against itself: the administration pledged a P4,000 minimum wage and has not delivered it, yet now trumpets that one or two new investors will pay P5,000 – a figure he warned raises expectations local employers “simply cannot meet.” “A promise on wages must be kept by Government, not passed on to employers.” He was equally sharp on arrears: when the State delays paying a small contractor, “a payment delayed by Government becomes a salary delayed in a household.” He proposed a published schedule for settling verified arrears and that the Bank of Botswana windfall be ring-fenced for those arrears and for capital projects – “not swallowed by recurrent spending.”

Fifth, confidence and credit. Investment needs predictability, he said, and businesses are unsettled by abrupt policy shifts. Major policy changes should carry consultation, an impact assessment and “one coherent message from Government,” with licences and permits decided within published timelines. On credit – which Econsult reports has contracted this year even as banks sit on high liquidity – he urged bookkeeping and compliance support alongside CEDA and BDC finance, faster land-title registration so citizens can borrow against their land, and expanded credit guarantees.

Sixth, the informal economy. There is an economy that “rarely appears in Government speeches,” he said – the bus ranks and markets, the hair salons, welding shops and food stalls. Too often the official response is to move vendors, confiscate goods and levy fines. “We cannot preach entrepreneurship in the morning and demolish its trading space in the afternoon.” The task, he argued, is not to clear people from the streets but to help them become “sustainable, bankable enterprises” — through secure serviced trading spaces, consultation before any relocation, simple micro-enterprise registration and a fair share of public procurement.

The De Beers question: ownership versus value

If the rescue plan was the speech’s spine, its most pointed passage was reserved for the President’s announcement that Botswana will double its stake in De Beers from 15 to 30 per cent and become the company’s largest single shareholder.

Saleshando did not oppose the ambition. He interrogated the arithmetic of it, through a parable. “When the head of a family announces that the family will buy into a business, that does not automatically mean a better life for the family.” The family, he said, would ask the obvious questions. Is the business profitable? If not, do we have the skills and the money to make it profitable? Can we afford to buy it and keep it running? Will we be better off? And is this the right time to commit our savings?

He then marshalled what is already public, and the picture was sobering. Laboratory-grown diamonds, produced mainly in China and India, already hold 20 to 25 per cent of the market and could reach 30 to 40 per cent by 2030. In the third quarter of this year, De Beers’ average selling price was 45 per cent lower than a year earlier. The company posted a loss in the first half. And Anglo American is selling De Beers precisely so it can pivot to copper.

Against that backdrop he fired the questions the address left unanswered. Has a sale agreement been signed? What is the price of the additional 15 per cent, and how will it be paid for while public debt heads towards 45 per cent of GDP? Does Government have a plan to revive the fortunes of natural diamonds? And, most pointedly: “If De Beers runs into financial difficulty, will Botswana, as its largest shareholder, have the muscle to rescue it, or will we sink with it?”

Then came the distinction that carried the argument. “Owning more of the mine is not the same as owning more of the value chain.” The real prize, he insisted, is more diamonds cut and polished at home – noting that local cutting and polishing firms have been retrenching workers because they cannot secure enough stones mined from Botswana’s own soil. “More shares will not, by themselves, create a single new job.”

He offered an alternative use of capital; that Government seriously consider stakes in the country’s copper mines, including Khoemacau, “while copper prices are strong” –  and a precondition for the De Beers purchase: that Botswana’s own professionals test the business case before any commitment. “Sentiment cannot be the basis for a decision that will bind future generations.” He signalled that the Botswana Congress Party will ask the appropriate parliamentary committee to exercise full oversight of the transaction.

Diversification, measured by what it produces

Saleshando’s broader quarrel was with diversification as rhetoric. Under the BETP, he noted, Government projected 512,000 jobs – yet has not given the nation a consolidated figure for how many actually exist. He proposed a quarterly BETP scorecard listing every project, its budget, what has been spent, what has been built, and the jobs it has produced.

Beyond the scorecard he called for enforceable local-procurement targets, supply chains built deliberately around every major investment, phased beneficiation requirements for critical minerals such as copper – following Zimbabwe and Namibia, which have restricted exports of unprocessed lithium – and water and electricity treated as preconditions for every industrial and special economic zone. “Before the next investor is announced, tell us where the water will come from.” Tourism, he added, remains “on the edge” of recovery plans; Maun, gateway to the Okavango Delta, should become a destination in its own right and a green city that protects the Thamalakane River.

Where government is judged

The speech then moved to the places citizens actually encounter the State – “the clinic, the classroom, the kraal and the land board.” On health, the BCP supports National Health Insurance but insists on first fixing existing facilities: with nine in ten Batswana already living within five to eight kilometres of a clinic, he said, the problem is not the number of clinics but “the quality of care inside them.” He called for a monthly dashboard of essential-medicines availability at every facility. On education, he contrasted a plan for 100 new schools with more than a thousand existing ones needing repair, citing his own office’s replacement of blackboards with more than 200 whiteboards across 14 Ngamiland schools as proof that “a learning environment can be transformed without new buildings.”

He demanded full disclosure on the African Hero initiative – of which the President is founding chairman, backed by the Moti Group, whose owner financed the UDC’s 2019 campaign – warning that a reported 17-year lease-to-own arrangement would leave taxpayers, not philanthropy, to foot the bill. “When the President sits on both sides of the table, every agreement… must be laid before this House.” He quoted former United States Ambassador Howard Van Vranken: “If you run with dogs, people will assume that you have fleas.”

On agriculture, he reframed the foot-and-mouth crisis – four outbreaks this year, a European Union suspension of beef imports, livestock output down almost half and abattoir output by more than sixty per cent – as “a household income crisis” for the roughly 100,000 households that draw income from the sector, and called for an urgent Livestock Recovery Fund. On land, he noted that three successive addresses have produced no comprehensive reform, and backed a single Land Management Authority with less ministerial discretion. On children, he welcomed the P300 Child Support Grant – proposed, he said, in the BCP’s 2024 manifesto – while urging that its twelve-month limit be reviewed. And on gender-based violence, he reproached the address for saying “far too little,” demanding it become “a measurable national undertaking.”

Three addresses, one test

Saleshando closed by holding the administration to its own consistency. In 2024 the theme was “Transforming Botswana for Inclusive Growth”; in 2025, “The Steady Path”; this year, the “steady path continues.” Consistency of vision, he allowed, is welcome. But “consistency of promises must be matched by consistency of delivery.”

“This Government has become better at announcing programmes than at accounting for them,” he said. “A programme does not become an achievement because it has been launched. A policy does not become a service because it has been approved. A project does not become infrastructure because ground breaking took place.”

The challenge he issued to the President was a single sentence with three refusals: do not give the nation another vision without an execution plan; do not promise young people jobs without a credible strategy to create them; do not call for diversification without showing which industries are being built.

“The steady path must not become a holding pattern,” he said. “The promise of transformation must not become a permanent announcement. And the patience of Batswana must never be mistaken for acceptance of the status quo.”