Court of Appeal rebukes Seretse’s lawyers over missing arguments

Laone Rasaka49 minutes ago1085 min

A tense exchange unfolded at the Court of Appeal this week after lawyers for Khulaco Proprietary Limited, a company linked to businessman Bakang Seretse, failed to file the heads of argument the court had directed them to submit.

Instead, Plaatjie Taupedi Attorneys sent the court a letter raising procedural objections and requesting further material, including the official record of the earlier proceedings. Khulaco’s lawyer, Samuel Plaatjie, told the full bench that the applicants could not properly address the judges’ questions without that record. He asked for an opportunity to obtain it and supplement their papers before the matter proceeded to argument.

The bench was unconvinced. Justice Bess Nkabinde reminded Plaatjie that counsel’s duty is to assist the court by making substantive submissions on the issues it has identified. She also noted that the hearing could not simply be deferred when no formal application for postponement had been filed.

Presiding Justice Goemekgabo Tebogo-Maruping likewise expressed the court’s displeasure, stressing that correspondence was no substitute for heads of argument. Lawyers for the Attorney General, Tshiamo Rantao and Mboki Chilisa, were then permitted to proceed with their submissions, having complied with the court’s directive.

 

The dispute behind the exchange

The case, CACGB-105-25, is an application by Khulaco and another party against the Attorney General and four other respondents. The applicants seek reconsideration of a final judgment previously delivered by the Court of Appeal.

Before the hearing, the Registrar wrote to the parties setting out three questions on which the bench required argument. The first was whether exceptional circumstances must exist before the court can exercise jurisdiction to reconsider one of its own decisions. The second was whether Khulaco’s founding papers adequately pleaded such circumstances. The third was whether the supporting affidavits contained facts capable of establishing them.

Plaatjie Taupedi Attorneys contended that it would be procedurally unfair to require answers before the applicants received the complete record. They said Khulaco’s original application had sought certified appeal documents, audio recordings, transcripts of oral argument and judicial notes. In their view, that material was needed to address concerns about the treatment of factual disputes in the original proceedings.

The applicants also questioned the composition of the panel. They noted that Court of Appeal President Justice Tebogo Tau is named as a respondent and sat on the panel that delivered the judgment now under challenge. Although they acknowledged that the court’s rules ordinarily empower the Judge President to constitute appeal panels, they queried whether that power should be exercised in a case involving her own earlier decision.

The lawyers made clear that they were not alleging actual bias or personal impropriety. Their concern, they said, was the appearance of judicial impartiality.

In their letter, they asked the court to suspend its directive to file heads of argument until the complete record was supplied. As an alternative, they proposed converting the hearing scheduled for 12 November 2026 into a case-management session.